BOOK: The Battle Off Samar


This book has been edited to fit the internet.

The Battle Off Samar - Taffy III at Leyte Gulf

SECOND EDITION

< Condensed Internet Version >

Copyright © 2001 Robert Jon Cox
All rights reserved
Ivy Alba Press, LLC


Time-Line, Events, & Comments

What makes this book unique is the use of a time-line for all events, all listed in chronological, time-line order. The events in Chapters two through nine are listed in the order in which the author believes they occurred. Entries listed simply as "EVENT" are also placed in a chronological, time-line order and are closely related in time to the last numbered "time" event. Comments by the author associated with events are often listed also. Entries are displayed as follows:

0708 A time-specific event, in the order in which the author believes they actually occurred.
EVENT A specific event, closely related in time to the last numbered "time" event.
A/C Author's Comment. A personal explanation of events by the author.

Chapter 13

1200 to END
SURVIVORS' PLIGHT

Wednesday, October 25, 1944


EVENT     The surviving escort carriers of Taffy III continue southward. Destroyer HEERMANN and destroyer escorts BUTLER, DENNIS, and RAYMOND are left behind to rescue the survivors of CVE ST LO. Nine hundred thirty-two men are rescued by the escorts.

RESCUE SHIPS OF USS ST LO (CVE 63)

Rescue Ships 

HEERMANN
BUTLER
DENNIS
RAYMOND

Total men rescued

Survivors

260
128
434
110

 932

A/C     The speed of the four remaining screening ships of Taffy III was limited to about 15 knots, due to the damage HEERMANN sustained earlier that morning. After picking up ST LO’s survivors, they sped back toward the escort carriers only to realize they would not catch up before darkness set in. Commander Hathaway, aboard HEERMANN, later directed BUTLER and RAYMOND to proceed ahead and catch up with the escort carriers before sunset.

Several of the men listed above were from CVEs WHITE PLAINS and KALININ BAY composite squadrons VC-4 and VC-3.

Sadly, due to confusion, the men of HOEL, JOHNSTON, ROBERTS, and GAMBIER BAY would not be rescued for at least another two days. I have deliberately chosen not to write in detail of their pitiful ordeal as I feel I could not do it the justice it deserves. Many survivors, including my great-uncle Virgil Cox, refused to talk about it.

1230     More aircraft from RADM Stump's Taffy II attack the remaining ships of Centre Force.

1236     Harassed by Taffy II's effective air attacks, Centre Force reverses course once again and heads north for San Bernardino Strait and the Sibuyan Sea.

1314     More carrier-based U.S. aircraft are sighted by the lookout of Centre Force.

1322     Heavy cruiser HIJMS SUZUYA, which lingered in a damaged condition since early morning, is abandoned and sinks. A Japanese destroyer stands by and aids the survivors.

1323     Centre Force comes under air attack by the aircraft sighted nine minutes earlier. The aircraft harass the Japanese for about fifteen minutes causing minor damage to a few ships.

1350     Aboard DE DENNIS, rescue operations for the survivors of CVE ST LO are considered completed. In the company of DD HEERMANN and destroyer escorts RAYMOND and BUTLER, a search though the day’s battle area for more survivors from the sunken ship’s of the task unit is commenced.

1409     More U.S. aircraft arrive and continue to harass Centre Force.

1432     The crew of DE DENNIS secures from general quarters. War cruising condition Baker is set.

1500     Vice Admiral McCain’s Task Group 38.1 launches another carrier strike consisting of twenty fighters, twenty bombers, and thirteen Avenger torpedo-bombers from the heavy carriers HORNET and HANCOCK. The IJN Centre Force escapes this attack without further damage.

1530     A raft with three men inside is sighted by DE DENNIS.

1540     Destroyer Escort DENNIS stops to pick up the three survivors.

1546     With the survivors onboard, DE DENNIS continues on base course 110° T, speed 10 knots.

1550     Continuing the search for survivors, DE DENNIS forms screen 53, USF 10A, position 3300, speed 15 knots, using DD HEERMANN as the guide. Destroyer Escorts RAYMOND and BUTLER assume their position within the search formation.

1600     Keeping pressure on the Japanese, another small air strike attacks Centre Force.

1622     Unable to speed southward fast enough, Task Force 34 is dissolved. Under the command of RADM Badger the fast battleships IOWA and NEW JERSEY, light cruisers BILOXI, VINCENNES, and MIAMI, and eight destroyers are redesignated as Task Force 34.5. They are ordered to speed ahead at 28 knots in an attempt to reach San Bernardino Strait before VADM Kurita's Centre Force. The remaining ships of the dissolved Task Force 34 are left behind with RADM Bogan's carriers. Task Force 34.5 RADM Badger

Battleships
IOWA
NEW JERSEY

Light Cruisers
BILOXI
VINCENNES
MIAMI

Destroyers
Eight ships

A/C     The battleships IOWA and NEW JERSEY were capable of sustained speeds approaching 33 knots, the other four battleships were capable of about 28 knots for short periods. Admiral Halsey decided to further divide his forces and sent the faster ships ahead in an attempt to catch VADM Kurita before his force entered San Bernardino Strait.

A/C      Task Force 34.5, the force sent ahead to deal with the IJN Centre Force, was considered by many as less than adequate to deal effectively with the surviving Japanese force. The IJN Centre Force still contained four battleships, two heavy cruisers, and several destroyers. Rear Admiral Badger's two battleships, three light cruisers, and eight destroyers would have their hands full if they caught up with Centre Force.

1625     Destroyer escorts BUTLER and RAYMOND are released by DD HEERMANN to catch up with the unescorted escort carriers of Taffy III before darkness sets in.

LARGE GUN FORCE COMPARISON
Task Force 34.5 and the IJN Centre Force
Showdown at San Bernardino Strait

U.S. Task Force 34.5

2 Battleships 18 16-inch guns
3 Light Cruisers 27 6-inch guns

IJN Centre Force

1 Battleship 9 18.1-inch guns
1 Battleship 8 16-inch guns
2 Battleships 16 14-inch guns
2 Heavy Cruisers 18 8-inch guns

1640     The last U.S. air strike of the day arrives off Samar consisting of about 40 aircraft. The Japanese warships are able to evade serious damage but retire with the major of the capital ships trailing oil and battle-scared from the days fight off Samar.

1647     Continuing their search for survivors, DD HEERMANN with Destroyer Escorts DENNIS, RAYMOND, and BUTLER change course to 120° T, speed 15 knots.

1700     Destroyer HEERMANN with Destroyer Escorts DENNIS, RAYMOND, and BUTLER change course to 150° T.

1705     Destroyer Escorts BUTLER and RAYMOND are ordered by OTC in DD HEERMANN to leave the formation and proceed independently to the location of the remaining escort carriers of Task Unit 77.4.3.

1716     In compliance from orders from Commander LCI(L) Flotillas, rescue vessels get under way, anchored near Dio Island, San Pedro Bay, Leyte Gulf, from alongside USS ARL 41. They proceed to rendezvous near USS BLUE RIDGE, anchored in San Pedro Bay. Upon receipt of written orders, Task Group 78.12 is established consisting of 2 PC's (Patrol Craft) and 5 LCI’s (Landing Craft, Infantry).

1727     Vice Admiral Kurita informs ADM Toyoda he is heading for San Bernardino Strait. The remnant vessels of Centre Force head for the strait at 24 knots with the stragglers following at best speed.

RESCUE SHIPS OF TASK GROUP 78.12
LCDR J. A .Baxter, USN
Rescue Ships

PC-623 (flagship)
PC-1119
LCI-34
LCI-71
LCI-337
LCI-340
LCI-341

Survivors

260
183
115
175
85
245
90

Total men rescued 1,153

1810     Destroyer HEERMANN and DE DENNIS change course to 120° T.

1900     After embarking a Medical Officer, LTJG Lucas, and one Corpsman, PHM1 Wattengel, the rescue vessels depart Leyte Gulf en route to the reported battle area. The area to search for survivors of CVE GAMBIER BAY, DD HOEL, DD JOHNSTON, and DE ROBERTS is given as latitude 11 degrees 15 minutes North, Longitude 125 degrees 30 minutes east.

1921     Flooding in the forward compartment of DE DENNIS is brought under control.

1925     Vice Admiral Kurita receives a dispatch from ADM Toyoda:

"IF THERE IS AN OPPORTUNITY TO DO SO, THE FIRST DIVERSION ATTACK FORCE WILL CONTACT AND DESTROY WHAT IS LEFT OF THE ENEMY TONIGHT. THE OTHER FORCES WILL COORDINATE THEIR ACTION WITH THE ABOVE. IF THERE IS NO CHANCE OF ENGAGING THE ENEMY IN NIGHT BATTLE TONIGHT, THE MAIN BODY OF THE MOBILE FLEET AND THE FIRST DIVERSION ATTACK FORCE WILL PROCEED TO THEIR REFUELING POINTS AS ORDERED BY THEIR RESPECTIVE COMMANDERS."

A/C     This dispatch was sent based upon the exaggerated battle reports sent by VADM Kurita earlier. At this point Centre Force had no stomach for further battle and proceeding towards San Bernardino Strait and retirement.

1949     Destroyer HEERMANN and DE DENNIS change course to 082° T.

2000     Seventh Fleet destroyers SPROSTON, HALE, and PICKING, dispatched by VADM Kinkaid, join up with the screenless escort carriers of Taffy III.

A/C     In regard to the escort carriers steaming ahead alone for several hours, RADM Sprague later commented, "...we had been through so much by then, that it didn't seem to matter whether we had escorts with us or not...."

2130     The surviving warships of Centre Force begin the passage of San Bernardino Strait.

Dick Grattidge
Crewmember
Rescue Ship LCI(R) 337

"Off and on all day I was in the harness of #3 20mm gun shooting at Jap planes. When we weren't at GQ our ship was fighting fires on burning ships and transferring the wounded to hospital ships. Somehow our steering had gone out from the wheelhouse, so when we got our orders to go on the rescue mission, I was assigned to the aft steering compartment to steer the ship manually.

Once we started picking up survivors (from GAMBIER BAY) I got relieved from steering. I went to the bow and threw a hand line to those in the water and helped bring them up over the side by the deck house. With our spot light on the men in the water we could see sharks amongst the guys as we were pulling them out as fast as we could.

On our way back to port with 172-176 survivors from GAMBIER BAY I saw a man sitting against the aft deck house with white bones showing in his elbow of his right arm. I went to the forward crews compartment to see if there was a bunk for him. Every bunk was taken by the more seriously wounded and our pharmacist mate and some of the crew were giving morphine shots and bandaging men."

A/C     Vice Admiral Kurita knew his force would come under heavy U.S. air attacks the following day as his force withdrew westward. He therefore sent his shore-based air commanders the following dispatch:

"IN VIEW OF THE ONE-SIDEDNESS OF THE DECISIVE ACTION CARRIED OUT TODAY, THE 25TH, THERE IS MUCH LIKELIHOOD OF THE ENEMY’S ATTEMPTING TO CARRY OUT REVENGE ATTACKS AGAINST US WITH THE ENTIRE STRENGTH OF THE REMAINDER OF HIS TASK FORCE. IT IS PROBABLE THAT CONTACT WOULD BE MADE IN THE VICINITY TO THE EAST OR NORTH OF LEGASPI ON THE 26TH. WE ARE OF THE OPINION THAT THE SITUATION MAY OFFER EXCELLENT OPPORTUNITY FOR THE SHORE-BASED AIR FORCE UNITS TO STRIKE THE FIRST BLOW AGAINST THE ENEMY AND GAIN CONTROL OF THE AIR."

2140     A night scout plane from CVL INDEPENDENCE reports that the ships of Centre Force are entering San Bernardino Strait in single column. The DD NOWAKI, left behind to aid the sinking CA CHIKUMA to take off her crew, is also sighted.

A/C     When Centre Force entered San Bernardino Strait once again unopposed, the door slammed shut on what would have been ADM Halsey’s chance to fight it out with his new, fast-battleships. Another interesting "what if" question arises. Would NEW JERSEY and IOWA have been able to deal with Centre Force? What would have been the greatest battleship-to-battleship match-up in the history of the world would never happen, i.e. Japan’s monstrous YAMATO versus the American IOWA’s.

EVENT     Unable to cover San Bernardino Strait in time to attack Centre Force, Task Force 34.5 dispatches the light cruisers BILOXI, MIAMI, and VINCENNES, and destroyers MILLER, OWEN, and LEWIS HANCOCK to attack the straggler DD NOWAKI.

0054     Light cruisers BILOXI, MIAMI, VINCENNES open fire on DD NOWAKI and set her ablaze. She quickly slows to 13 knots.

0103      Dead in the water, DD NOWAKI is finished off by the destroyers.

A/C     Destroyer NOWAKI had many more men aboard her than usual when she was sunk. She spent the better part of the day picking up survivors from the disabled heavy cruiser CHIKUMA. The ordeal faced by the survivors of CHIKUMA was most unfortunate.

The rescue ships arrived at the designated area shortly before sunrise on Thursday, October 26. LCIs 340 and 341 were unable to make 10 knots and fell behind the Patrol Craft.

End of Time-line

During the day and night of October 26 debris and oil slicks had been noted from time to time. Subsequent to time of picking up the first survivors and until about 0940, October 27 a total of 172 living and 1 dead were picked by LCI(L) 337. Of this total, approximately 25 were stretcher cases from battle wounds, approximately an additional 60 had sustained battle wounds of minor to major character and all were suffering from shock and exposure.

The search was continued under direction of Commander Task Group 78.12 until 0055 on October 27 at which time LCI(L) 337 sighted and brought aboard the first of its survivors.

At about 0940 on October 27, with no additional survivors in sight, an order was received to take station in cruising formation for return to Leyte Gulf. Aside from a single enemy SALLY or BETTY type two engine bomber which was observed to closely approach LCI(G) 34 as she was preparing to assume cruising station at about 0945, the return trip to Leyte was accomplished without incident. A medical officer from a destroyer escort on patrol near Dinagat Island was embarked for a period of about one hour upon arrival at mouth of Leyte Gulf to render emergency treatment to two survivors.

Upon arrival at San Pedro Bay, survivors were transferred to USS LST 464 Hospital Ship and USS PIEDMONT.

The dog tags and very limited personal effects of two additional men were buried at sea by the survivors prior to being picked up.

A/C     At the end of Taffy III's tribulation, heavily damaged DD HEERMANN and DE DENNIS went on to Kossol Passage for much needed repairs. Destroyer escorts BUTLER and RAYMOND, only lightly damaged during the Battle Off Samar, went to Leyte Gulf to refuel and drop off survivors from the ST LO.

A/C     The four surviving escort carriers of Taffy III, FANSHAW BAY, WHITE PLAINS, KALININ BAY, and KITKUN BAY, with their newly provided replacement escorts went on to Manus for much needed rest and repairs.

A/C     The survivors of CVE GAMBIER BAY, DD HOEL, DD JOHNSTON, and DE SAMUEL B. ROBERTS were not rescued until October 27, after spending over two days in the water adrift.

A/C     The author’s great-uncle Virgil Cox of USS GAMBIER BAY (CVE 73) was one of those who were fortunate enough to survive the greatest naval battle in history.


Purchase the Fourth Edition of my book


Forward to Chapter 14

Return to Book Index

Return to Main Menu


Honor the Missing in Action and Killed in Action of Taffy III

We do remember.  We won't forget.


Robert Jon Cox webmaster@bosamar.com
last revised July 12, 2008
Copyright Robert Jon Cox 1996-2008 all rights reserved
Void where prohibited.