BOOK: The Battle Off Samar


This book has been edited to fit the internet.

The Battle Off Samar - Taffy III at Leyte Gulf

SECOND EDITION

< Condensed Internet Version >

Copyright © 2001 Robert Jon Cox
All rights reserved
Ivy Alba Press, LLC


Time-Line, Events, & Comments

What makes this book unique is the use of a time-line for all events, all listed in chronological, time-line order. The events in Chapters two through nine are listed in the order in which the author believes they occurred. Entries listed simply as "EVENT" are also placed in a chronological, time-line order and are closely related in time to the last numbered "time" event. Comments by the author associated with events are often listed also. Entries are displayed as follows:

0708 A time-specific event, in the order in which the author believes they actually occurred.
EVENT A specific event, closely related in time to the last numbered "time" event.
A/C Author's Comment. A personal explanation of events by the author.

Chapter 7

0707 to 0730
SANCTUARY, COUNTER-ATTACK, AND DEFEND

Wednesday, October 25, 1944


0707    Heavy rain pours down across the decks of the leading escort carriers of Taffy III. Rear Admiral Sprague takes advantage of this opportunistic sanctuary and steers his task unit directly into its heart. Visibility decreases rapidly. Increasing in volume, heavy black funnel smoke and FS (chemical) smoke from the escort carriers, destroyers, and destroyer escorts obstructs the Japanese line of sight. As a result of the natural and man-made screen, the accuracy of the heavy caliber Japanese gunfire decreases significantly. The multicolored shell splashes exploding near the warships of Taffy III decline significantly.

 

CTU 77.4.3/COMCARDIV 25 Action Report
RADM C.A.F. Sprague, USN

At 0706, the enemy was closing with disconcerting rapidity, and volume and accuracy of fire was increasing. At this point, it did not appear that any of our ships could survive another five minutes of the heavy caliber fire being received, and some counteraction was urgently and immediately required. The Task Unit was surrounded by the ultimate of desperate circumstances. All escorts were ordered to attack the enemy with torpedoes. At this time, direct view of the enemy was obscured by smoke and results of our escort’s attack could not be ascertained, but it is believed that, regardless of hits, they succeeded in turning the battleships away at least momentarily, and created a diversion of immense value.

About this time we intercepted a fairly heavy rain squall and while in it changed course to the right. The combination of rain and smoke made visibility very poor and enemy fire slackened and fell off in accuracy.

A/C    The smoke screen was used to great effect by all ships of Taffy III, albeit it was one of the few advantages they held. The destroyers and destroyer escorts zigzagged in and around the fleeing escort carriers, winding the smoke layers into a defensive shield. The hot, humid Philippine climate aided to combine the mixture of black fuel smoke and white chemical smoke, making them mix most effectively. Combined with the current intermittent rain squall, it greatly neutralized the Japanese gunfire accuracy and was a contributing factor to the escape of Taffy III...for the time being...

0707    Aboard escort carrier ST LO, a salvo is observed to splash ahead of the ship, slightly off the starboard bow. A series of four shells splash and explode in a line, the first shell hitting the water about 200 yards from the ship.

A/C    Help from Seventh Fleet surface forces, consisting of RADM Oldendorf’s Fire Support Group, the old, slow battleships, was about three hours away at the southern end of Leyte Gulf.

EVENT    Local US anti-submarine patrols from the other Taffies attack the ships of Centre Force, strafing their decks and dropping depth charges.

A/C    These planes were already in the air when Centre Force initially attacked Taffy III. As mentioned earlier, their pilots were untrained in anti-surface ship strikes, but certainly made up for their lack of anti-shipping training by their shear determination.

0708    Word is passed via TBS on the escort carriers of Taffy III, "All carriers launch all aircraft." Sixty-five fighters and forty-four TBM aircraft from the CVEs are launched. Several aircraft are unarmed or under-fueled due to their hasty launch. Only a handful of the bombers are armed with torpedoes. Escort carriers WHITE PLAINS and KITKUN BAY manage to launch General Motors FM-2 fighters which carry bombs.

A/C    The flight deck and hanger crews of the escort carriers worked at a feverish pace to prepare their aircraft for flight, fighting the rain soaked decks, in addition to their Japanese foes.

A/C    The courage displayed by the American pilots was enormous. The fact that they were preparing to attack a powerful armored surface force with little or no armor piercing ordnance or formal training was extraordinary. It would be nearly impossible to stop the heavily armored Japanese warships without armor-piercing ordnance or torpedoes. After expending whatever ordnance they left their carriers with, many pilots made dry runs over the Japanese warships, breaking up their formations and interrupting their pursuit of the fleeing escort carriers. For the most part, this tactic worked well, significantly contributing to the final outcome of the battle. The American pilots first concentrated on the battleships since they were the most potent threat early in the battle. It was during this initial counter-attack that IJN BB KONGO’s main range finder was disabled by the American fighters.

LT Dick Roby, USNR
USS GAMBIER BAY (CVE 73)
Composite Squadron VC-10
General Motors FM-2 Fighter Pilot

"After General Quarters was secured Gene Seitz and I were the "ready" VF (fighter) pilots; there were no VT (torpedo) pilots in that status at approximately 0655. Elmo Waring alerted us that the Japanese fleet was 24 miles away and to man all aircraft. I took time to get him on the intercom and told him to get the pilots out of the wardroom. By this time I got to the flight deck. I discovered Dugan was in #2, I was #3, Rocky Phillips was in #4. We took off as the ship was getting into the wind and were vectored NW of the Task Unit to intercept two destroyers. We made two sets of strafing runs on them, going down through a thin cloud cover. They apparently had no radar fire controlled AA as their fire was very poor. After the second run they turned around and retreated on a course of about 350 degrees."

0708    A TBM-1C Avenger Torpedo-bomber of Composite Squadron VC-10 is brought up on deck via the forward elevator aboard CVE GAMBIER BAY.

0708    Another salvo, similar to the first, is seen aboard CVE ST LO, landing the same distance ahead slightly off the port bow.

EVENT    Commander Evans rapidly closes the distance between IJN Cruiser Division Seven and DD JOHNSTON. She pushes through the water at flank bell, creating a large bow wave. A long line of thick black funnel smoke is laid behind her as she goes.

A/C    JOHNSTON had already closed the approaching Japanese fleet by about nine miles since the initial contact with Centre Force. Commander Evans was displaying his true fighting spirit which led the way for the other screening ships of the task unit throughout the morning. The small Americans warships were commanded fearlessly in the face of their superior enemy.

EVENT    Several of the pursuing Japanese warships are forced to take evasive maneuvers in lieu of air attack, interrupting their pursuit of the escort carriers of Taffy III.

A/C    This was the norm for most of the engagement. The Japanese had no idea what the attacking aircraft carried ordnance-wise and therefore had to treat all aircraft as a potential threat.

0709    TBS - v Taffy 3, "ALL CARRIERS LAUNCH ALL AIRCRAFT."

0710    Steaming in single column at 33 knots, IJN heavy cruisers KUMANO, SUZUYA, TONE, and CHIKUMA of Cruiser Division Seven close the escort carriers on a southeasterly heading. They are the nearest threat to Taffy III. While maintaining their current course, they are on the verge of outflanking the escort carriers on their port quarter.

0710    The TBM-1C Avenger Torpedo-bomber of Composite Squadron VC-10 brought up on deck only a few minutes earlier is launched via the catapult loaded with a torpedo.

0710    Six TBM-1C torpedo bombers of Composite Squadron VC-5 are launched from CVE KITKUN BAY.

0710    The deployment of the screening ships in the rear of the CVE formation for the purpose of generating a smoke screen is now complete. All escort vessels now effectively contribute to the smoke screen as more ships enter the rain squall.

0710    Destroyer JOHNSTON charges the enemy cruisers at 30 knots and fires her forward 5-inch guns at Cruiser Division Seven flagship CA KUMANO at 18,000 yards, scoring several hits on her superstructure. Heavy cruisers KUMANO, SUZUYA, TONE, and CHIKUMA are in position to return fire and do so with main armament of 8-inch guns. All shells miss their small target, about nine miles away and closing rapidly.

0710    TBS - v Taffy 3, "ALL SHIPS IN THIS GROUP TURN TO COURSE 080."

0710    TBS - Taffy 3 v FIDO, "I HAVE BEEN HIT."

A/C    WHITE PLAINS, aka "FIDO", reported an armor-piercing hit which passed completed through her thin hull without exploding, causing little or no damage. Her speed was unimpeded.

LT Robert C. Hagen, USN
Gunnery & Senior Surviving Officer
USS JOHNSTON (DD 557)

"We were engaging many ships at only medium ranges. There were several occasions where the ship still could have crept away and escaped further damage which she was continuing to receive. At this time we had taken 12 to 14 hits. We had two guns that were fully in operation, two others that could have fired only in manual. Our maximum speed was still 15 knots. Killed and wounded littered our decks.

The Captain, Commander Evans, was injured rather severely at 0730, two and a half hours before we abandoned ship, to the extent of a couple of fingers blown off, an unknown number of shrapnel holes in his back and superficial wounds about his face and neck, all of which were drawing considerable blood. Despite these things the Captain fought the ship as no other man has ever fought a ship."

0710    Japanese battleships YAMATO , NAGATO, and HARUNA cease fire on the fleeing U.S. warships due to a lack of visibility caused by the smoke screen and rain squall. Aggressive BB KONGO to the northward, clear of the smoke and rain, continues to fire on the American task unit.

0710    Japanese Destroyer Squadron Two, led by CL NOSHIRO with seven highly capable destroyers, is ordered to follow in the rear of the formation.

A/C    The decision not to use these destroyers aggressively early in the battle generated quite a bit of controversy with strategists and historians. Rightfully so, their removal from the early stages of the battle were another crucial decision which led to the escape of the American task unit.

0710    A Japanese warship, bearing 325° T, distance 14 miles, is picked up on radar by DE DENNIS.

EVENT    From the rear of the Japanese formation, battleships and light cruisers open fire upon DD JOHNSTON, all missing. Destroyer JOHNSTON expends over 200 rounds of 5-inch ammunition during her initial approach to the Japanese warships of Cruiser Division Seven.

A/C    Lone JOHNSTON was initially the nearest ship to the approaching Japanese. Once she was within range of the heavy cruisers’ guns, she was forced to maneuver wildly during her initial advance on the cruiser column.

0711    TBS - Taffy 2 v Taffy 3, "ENEMY BEARS 090 SPEED 30, AND 070 SPEED 30 KNOTS, DISTANCE 20 MILES."

A/C    From flagship FANSHAW BAY, RADM Sprague reports the enemies status to RADM Stump of Taffy II.

0711    TBS - v Taffy 3, "ALL SHIPS OF THIS COMMAND COME TO SHACKLE JIG BAKER UNSHACKLE."

A/C    All ships of the task unit are ordered to course 080° T.

0711    On the starboard quarter of the task unit, DE DENNIS changes course to 000° T to take cover in a rain squall.

0713    Escort Carrier ST LO enters the rain squall which is now a driving rain. All the escort carriers are laying smoke.

0715    TBS - Taffy 2 v Taffy 3, "ENEMY COMPOSED OF 6 BATTLESHIPS, 8 CRUISERS, ACCOMPANYING DESTROYERS. PLEASE SEND ALL AVAILABLE PLANES TO THIS AREA."

A/C    As circumstances and time permitted, RADM Sprague radioed for help and realized that the majority of assistance would come from the escort carries of Task Unit 77.4.2.

0715    Steaming eastward at flank speed, the tail-end escort carrier of Taffy III enters the rain squall. The CVEs flee in a circular formation about 2,500 yards in diameter. The escorts lay protective smoke in their rear, about 6,000 yards from the imaginary center of the formation.

0715    At a distance of about 12,000-15,000 yards IJN BB HARUNA opens fire on DD JOHNSTON and misses.

EVENT    The escort carriers of Taffy III, now inside the protective rain squall, are ordered by RADM Sprague to turn southward toward the safety of the other Taffies, Leyte Gulf, and Seventh Fleet.

A/C    In his attempt to save Taffy III, RADM Sprague also wanted to draw the Japanese warships away from San Bernardino Strait and within striking distance of the ships and aircraft of the U.S. fleets. He knew the most damage would be inflicted to Centre Force in open water by the aircraft of the fleets. Taffy II was currently less than 25 miles, perhaps as close as 20 miles, southeast of Taffy III, just over the horizon. After RADM Stump had received RADM Sprague’s initial distress call, he hastily began preparing his first strike from the escort carriers of his task unit.

0716    Rear Admiral Sprague, sensing the danger from the Japanese cruiser line, orders his three destroyers to counterattack with torpedoes. Rear Admiral Sprague is unaware JOHNSTON has already engaged the cruisers with gunfire and is preparing to deliver the first torpedo attack.

A/C    The three FLETCHER Class destroyers of Taffy III had a total of thirty torpedoes between them. The four BUTLER Class destroyer escorts combined could only muster twelve more. Knowing he was entirely out-gunned by the quickly advancing Japanese warships in every category, RADM Sprague was determined to use his destroyers primary weapons before it was too late.

0718    Inside the rain squall, a driving rain with visibility close to zero, CVE ST LO begins launching the aircraft of Composite Squadron VC-65. Four Avenger Torpedo Bombers and fifteen Wildcat Fighters are prepared for immediate launch.

A/C     During the launching, the range of the enemy main body closed rapidly to 25,000 yards and on down to 22,000 yards. Main battery salvoes from both the battleships and heavy cruisers had continued landing among the CVEs.

EVENT    Destroyer HOEL, commanded by Commander L. S. Kintberger, in response to RADM Sprague’s order, turns his ship and heads west to engage the lead ships of Centre Force.

A/C    Embarked in HOEL was Commander W. D. Thomas, the destroyer screen commander. All orders to the screening ships concerning their attack were directed to them via CDR Thomas.

EVENT    As DD HOEL exits the rain squall on her run towards the IJN Centre Force, BB YAMATO sights the American warship and fires on her without success.

0720    Already heavily in the melee with Cruiser Division Seven and in a good position to press her attack, DD JOHNSTON charges the advancing cruiser line at 27 knots. At 10,000 yards she completes her fire control solution and fires her full complement of ten torpedoes at the lead ship, CA KUMANO. All ten torpedoes are reported to run "hot, straight, and normal."

EM2 Glen E. Foster, USNR
Interior Communications Electrician
USS HOEL (DD 533)

"When GQ was sounded I took my station (in the emergency generator room) and donned the sound powered phones and heard that the whole Jap fleet was out there. Shortly thereafter we took a hit that knocked out the aft generator. The emergency diesel generator next to me started up and I was kept busy providing emergency power. I felt numerous hits that shook the whole ship and water started flowing into the compartment . . . . we tasted the water and found it to be fresh water so we surmised that a tank or pipe had sprung a leak . . . by this time communications had been knocked out and I had no idea what was happening topside except I kept feeling the ship taking hits and I could hear and feel our forward guns firing.

While I was working in front of the switchboard a hit into the forward fire room buckled the bulkhead and knocked the switchboard onto me . . . . steam started pouring into the compartment. It was then I decided it was time to get the hell out."

0720    TBS - v Taffy 3, "ALL CARRIERS REPORT WHETHER THEY HAVE LAUNCHED ALL PLANES. FIDO HAVE YOU LAUNCHED ALL PLANES? GEORGIA HAVE YOU LAUNCHED ALL PLANES?" .... v FIDO, "AFFIRMATIVE." .... v GEORGIA, "WILL LET YOU KNOW."

EVENT    Immediately after delivering her torpedo attack, DD JOHNSTON reverses course and retires toward the escort carriers inside her own smoke screen.

0723    TBS - Mercury 3 v Taffy 3, "ALL SHIPS TURN SHACKLE YOKE ITEM BAKER UNSHACKLE. DERBY AND DEXTER ACKNOWLEDGE." .... v DERBY, DEXTER, "WILCO OUT."

A/C    All ships of the task unit are ordered to course 110° T.

0723    Inside the rain squall, DE DENNIS changes course to 110° T.

0723    TBS - Mercury 3 v Taffy 3, "EXECUTE UPON RECEIPT TURN NINE. DERBY AND DEXTER ACKNOWLEDGE." .... v DERBY, DEXTER, "WILCO OUT."

A/C    The OTC ordered the escort carriers to turn southward. This was another pivotal point in the battle; a big gamble which paid off. Concealed by the rain squall and out of sight from the enemy, RADM Sprague gambled greatly by turning the task unit to the south and thereby decreasing the distance in which Centre Force could have to travel to cut off the task units retreat. Luck was with RADM Sprague and his task unit at this time as Centre Force blindly continued on an easternly course oblivious to the CVEs turn to the south. RADM Sprague later wrote:

"It was hard (to make this decision), because in so turning we moved in an arc -  roughly semicircular - and I feared the Jap commander would cut across the diameter and blast us out of the water as we emerged from our little squall. "

0724    Seven miles and closing, battleship KONGO comes into range of DD HOEL’s guns. HOEL fires her 5-inch gun’s at the large ship at 14,000 yards.

0724    TBS - Mercury 23 v Taffy 23, "FORM 330 FROM FLEET CENTER. DE’S FORM 045 FROM FLEET CENTER."

0725    Battleship KONGO returns fire with her 14-inch main batteries and hits DD HOEL's bridge. The resulting explosion on DD HOEL is so violent, it is seen by VADM Kurita on board BB YAMATO who believes she blew up. Several members of HOEL's bridge control party are killed. Destroyer HOEL, still afloat, is now running on one engine and has to be steered by hand.

LT Maurice F. Green, USN
USS HOEL (DD 533)

"We decided to fire a half salvo at the leading battleship and save the other half for the leading cruiser because it was definite that we would have to turn at least two columns of ships in order to be of any assistance in screening the CVEs...all the Japs turned and fled. There is no explanation why. They could have rubbed out every ship in our formation...

At 0725 we received the first hit on the bridge which destroyed our voice radio communications and also the remote Radar PPI on the bridge. This shell also killed several bridge personnel.... helmsman.... captain’s talker...

It was less than five minutes later that we received a hit on the main battery director putting it out of action and also killing our anti-aircraft officer, making it necessary for the anti-aircraft guns to go into local control. We had an officer at each 40 mm mount...there was nothing within range of the 40 mms to fire at..."

A/C    From the Japanese point of view, BB KONGO conducted some fine shooting that morning. Of all four battleships present, only BB KONGO's fire control solutions were consistently accurate and she was credited with hitting many of Taffy III’s ships.

EVENT    At 9,000 yards DD HOEL fires five of her torpedoes at BB KONGO which turns hard to port to evade them. Battleship KONGO fires her main battery once again and hits DD HOEL with two more 14-inch shells.

EVENT    The damage from the heavy shells cause DD HOEL’s rudder to jam. As a result, she heads straight toward BB KONGO for two perilous minutes before steering can be shifted aft; she slowly turns away, avoiding further damage.

A/C    HOEL was in rough shape by this time. After spending two minutes driving towards KONGO, she was able to regain control of her rudder. Now, practically directly under the guns of KONGO, she had to make best her retreat with only one engine.

0725    Battleship KONGO enters the rain squall and ceases firing on the Americans.

0725    Escort Carrier KITKUN BAY completes the launching of her 10 TBM torpedo bombers and 10 FM-2 fighters from Composite Squadron VC-5.

A/C    KITKUN BAY had nearly her full complement of aircraft on board when Centre Force attacked. From the time of the initial sighting and the sounding of General Quarters it took her only about 30 minutes to ready and launch 20 aircraft. No small feat on an escort carrier, let alone one that is under fire and in a rain squall!

0727    Heavy cruiser KUMANO is hit by at least one torpedo from DD JOHNSTON, possibly as many as three, almost severing her bow. Critically damaged, her speed drops to 16 knots and she drops out of the cruiser formation.

A/C    The Japanese cruiser division believed JOHNSTON was a BALTIMORE Class cruiser.

EVENT    Heavy cruiser SUZUYA, comes under extremely heavy air attack by Taffy aircraft. She is bombed twice and badly damaged. Veering to port, her speed is limited to 23 knots due to a ruptured fuel tank.

EVENT    With her division mate in more serious trouble than herself, CA SUZUYA stops to aid the severely wounded CA KUMANO.

A/C    Only one minute shy of 30 minutes into the Japanese bombardment the Americans had succeeded in placing two heavy units of Centre Force out of action for the remainder of the battle. The two MOGAMI Class heavy cruisers KUMANO and SUZUYA sported ten 8-inch guns and eight 5-inch guns apiece. Their early removal from the battle was paramount in the escape of the American task unit. Had they not been removed at this early stage, their 35 knot speed and heavy armament certainly would had given them the potential to play a major roll in the remainder of the battle. KUMANO would live one month longer, only to be sunk by Task Force 38 aircraft from the carrier TICONDEROGA. Later during the day, SUZUYA became a target for Taffy aircraft, floundered, and was scuttled by Centre Force destroyer OKINAMI.

0730    Running almost abeam of the cruiser line and with battleships closing from astern, DD JOHNSTON is hit by three 14-inch battleship and three 6-inch light cruiser shells, "...like a puppy being smacked by a truck...." Her after fire room and engine room are knocked out, all power to her three after 5-inch guns and gyrocompass are lost. The ship’s radar-search mast is broken off and comes to a rest, hanging near the bridge. Most important, power to the steering engine is cut off. With one engine remaining, her speed drops to 17 knots.

A/C    As JOHNSTON and HOEL were both hit with 14-inch shells, the battleship KONGO was effectively engaging the destroyers. Although severely crippled by the 14-inch hits, these two gallant destroyers would fight on.

0730    Battleship KONGO executes an emergency turn to starboard as she evades the torpedoes fired earlier by DD HOEL.

A/C    KONGO’s turn to starboard to comb HOEL’s torpedoes wakes kept her in the battle as it drew her on a course to close on the Americans.

0730    Destroyer Escort DENNIS changes course to 200° T.

EVENT    Caught in the middle of the approaching Japanese warships, one of the exploding shells kills three officers on DD JOHNSTON’s bridge. In addition, the concussion from the violent explosion rips the shirt off CDR Evans. He also loses two fingers on his left hand and suffers several small shrapnel wounds to his neck and back. Undaunted by his wounds, he continues to fight his ship in a heroic and gallant manner.

EVENT    Luck in the form of a rain squall finds DD JOHNSTON as she finds safe-haven in the same squall the escort carriers entered earlier. Once inside, the Japanese gunfire subsides and her men hastily begin emergency repairs to their heavily damaged ship.

SHIP

Torpedoes

Time

TARGET/RESULTS

Carried

Fired

HOEL

10

5

0725

BB KONGO, all miss

JOHNSTON

10

10

0727

CA KUMANO, one to three hits

Initial results of screening action.

A/C    This timely sanctuary gave JOHNSTON the time she needed to fabricate emergency repairs. Her bridge was utterly ruined by her engagement with the battleships. It was during this time that CDR Evans switched steering to manual control aft, via the JV phone circuit.

EVENT    Destroyer HOEL, with limited propulsion on one engine, is unable to put distance between herself and the Japanese warships. She continues to take heavy punishment. She is hit on her main battery director, putting it out of commission and killing the anti-aircraft officer. Her 40mm anti-aircraft guns are placed in local control.

EVENT    The fleeing escort carriers reach the south side of the quick moving rain squall. With their sanctuary passing by the side, the six fleeing escort carriers now exit the other side of the rain squall and continue on a southerly course with the warships of Centre Force in hot pursuit.


Purchase the Fifth Edition of my book


Forward to Chapter 8

Return to Book Index

Return to Main Menu


Honor the Missing in Action and Killed in Action of Taffy III

We do remember.  We won't forget.


Robert Jon Cox webmaster@bosamar.com
last revised January 22, 2012
Copyright Robert Jon Cox 1996-2010 all rights reserved
Void where prohibited.